At the risk of jumping down a conspiracy rabbit hole- what do you want to bet that Cynthia Glass was who they had in mind when hiring Atwell, but changed the script later so that the romance could be “real”?
Ooof you know you’re poking the bear asking me about Saint Margaret don’t you?? 😅
I’ve got to say, when you look at them: there’s no ambiguity there.
HA looks more like Cynthia Glass than Cynthia does.
And there’s physically no way to mistake this ^
(A brown-eyed brunette Englishwoman, doing an English accent…)
For a blonde, blue-eyed, American Southerner, is there?
I mean, they would never have even looked at someone like HA or Emily Blunt in casting, if that was the case, would they?
If they wanted Peggy in a Rebirth comic arc all they had to do was get a blonde American and put her in Cynthia’s place, and not include everything else that made her Cynthia-ish.
They could’ve still had her being a Virginian, later embedded with the French Resistance, wearing the beret, etc.
There was no reason to keep any Cynthia traits at all unless they started out with a Nazi and made a swap at the last minute, but were just too damn lazy to do a proper job of it.
If the looks were just meant to be an Easter Egg, there’d be no need for the English accent, either.
(And the guy who directed CATFA was also involved in the Indiana Jones movies, which include a… female Nazi spy love interest… who switches at the last minute. Hmm…)
If Peggy was originally meant to be revealed as a Nazi, it would even explain why Steve seems so un-bothered about her during CATFA (and why Cevans seems to pull so hard for Stucky in comparison).
It would scan, if Steve’s indifference was originally in the script to make it deliberately ambiguous and distance him from any later claims to loving a Nazi (while, of course, simultaneously allowing nutjob rightwingers to imagine that Captain ‘Murica would love a Nazi, so the Rat can still take their money.)
.
ed: I’ve been informed that the Agent Carter: Season One book confirms that she is, indeed, based on Cynthia Glass, as you can see here on Gbooks. So there it is. 🤷🏼♀️
.
You don’t even need to change anything about MCU!Peggy’s personality in the scripts to turn her into full blown Nazi Cynthia, either.
· long post · cynthia glass · p*ggy meta · antipeggy · it's not a conspiracy if it's literally just what they did · steggy is hydra trash party · anti st*ggy · antitony · toAyourQ · hey nonny · dat's me · meta · mcu meta · that AC book calls her shooting at steve a 'charming display of temper' · and the literal nazi 'ultimately compassionate' · for fucks sake · antisteggy · mcu critical · the anti-shakespeare: the more you look the worse it gets · pinned cuz for some reason these things don't show up in search results on my blog?? 👀😒











